Skip to main content

Written questions

Search written questions to Ministers and the replies they have received.

Filters
Asked by All MPs
Minister All Ministers
Portfolio Commerce and Consumer Affairs
Question published between

Dates refer to when the question was published, and are inclusive.

Showing 1 to 50 of 649 written question sets.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Duncan Webb

Member for Christchurch Central · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    On what date did Bill English send the email referred to by the Minister when he said in question time on 15 September 2026 " I am delighted to confirm those decreases, particularly around tinned spaghetti. I received a delighted email, a…

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

The reference to the email was intended to be a whimsical reference to Bill English making spaghetti pizza, rather than a factual anecdote.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Julie Anne Genter

Member for Rongotai · Green Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    What specific oversight mechanisms, if any, are in place to monitor the processing of Safeguard applications at MBIE?

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

Safeguard applications are subject to established oversight and quality assurance processes within MBIE. Investigations are undertaken in accordance with the requirements of the Trade (Safeguard Measures) Act 2014 and are overseen by…

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Julie Anne Genter

Member for Rongotai · Green Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    What steps, if any, is he taking to ensure that Provisional Safeguard Duties under the Trade (Safeguard Measures) Act 2014 are treated as a priority?

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

I have requested regular updates on the progress MBIE makes on investigations under the Trade (Safeguards Measures) Act 2014, including on Provisional Safeguard Duties. I refer the member to my response to written question 37854 (2026) for…

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Arena Williams

Member for Manurewa · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    What aides-mémoire, briefings, memos, notes, reports, or any other advice, if any, has the Minister or their Office received during the week beginning 7 September 2026, listed by agency, title and date received?

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

As per previous answers for written questions, I regularly request and receive advice on a range of topics. In the interest of transparency, a list of briefings and reports received by my office from the Ministry of Business, Innovation…

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Arena Williams

Member for Manurewa · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    What papers, if any, did the Minister take to Cabinet during the week beginning 7 September 2026, by title and date?

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

I regularly take papers to Cabinet across a range of topics. In the interest of transparency, I proactively release papers considered by Cabinet on the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment website…

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Arena Williams

Member for Manurewa · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    What aides-mémoire, briefings, memos, notes, reports, or any other advice, if any, has the Minister or their Office received during the week beginning 31 August 2026, listed by agency, title and date received?

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

I regularly request and receive advice on a range of topics. In the interest of transparency, a list of briefings and reports received by my office from the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment (MBIE) is regularly published on…

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Arena Williams

Member for Manurewa · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    What papers, if any, did the Minister take to Cabinet during the week beginning 31 August 2026, by title and date?

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

I regularly take papers to Cabinet across a range of topics. In the interest of transparency, I proactively release papers considered by Cabinet on the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment website…

Questions published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Francisco Hernandez

List MP · Green Party

Questions

  • 38920 (matches this search)

    How much, if any, was spent in the 2025/26 financial year in the Minister's departments, agencies, crown entities and any other bodies that the Minister is responsible for, if any, on artificial intelligence, including costs on training…

  • 38922 (matches this search)

    How much, if any, was spent in the 2024/25 financial year in the Minister's departments, agencies, crown entities and any other bodies that the Minister is responsible for, if any, on artificial intelligence, including costs on training…

  • 38931 (matches this search)

    How much, if any, was spent in the 2023/24 financial year in the Minister's departments, agencies, crown entities and any other bodies that the Minister is responsible for, if any, on artificial intelligence, including costs on training…

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

I am responsible for six Crown entities: Accreditation Council, Commerce Commission, External Reporting Board, Financial Markets Authority, Retirement Commission and Takeovers Panel. Providing the level of information sought by the member…

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Francisco Hernandez

List MP · Green Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    How much, if any, did the Minister’s departments, agencies, crown entities and any other bodies that the Minister is responsible for, if any, spend on consultancy costs, from 1 July 2024 - 30 June 2025?

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

I refer the member to the 'Workforce Size' information available on the Public Service Commission website: https://www.publicservice.govt.nz/data/workforce-data/public-sector-composition/workforce-size

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Francisco Hernandez

List MP · Green Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    How much, if any, did the Minister’s departments, agencies, crown entities and any other bodies that the Minister is responsible for, if any, spend on consultancy costs, from 1 July 2025 - 30 June 2026?

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

I refer the member to the 'Workforce Size' information available on the Public Service Commission website: https://www.publicservice.govt.nz/data/workforce-data/public-sector-composition/workforce-size. Expenditure for the period 1 April -…

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Francisco Hernandez

List MP · Green Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    How much was the total cost in New Zealand dollar terms, if any, of redundancy processes initiated, if any, in the Minister’s departments, agencies, crown entities and any other bodies that the Minister is responsible for, if any, since 27…

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

I am responsible for six Crown entities: Accreditation Council, Commerce Commission, External Reporting Board, Financial Markets Authority, Retirement Commission and Takeovers Panel. There has been a total cost of $2,570,186.65 in payments…

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Francisco Hernandez

List MP · Green Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    How many redundancy processes have been initiated, if any, in the Minister’s departments, agencies, crown entities and any other bodies that the Minister is responsible for, if any, since 27 November 2023?

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

I am responsible for six Crown entities: Accreditation Council, Commerce Commission, External Reporting Board, Financial Markets Authority, Retirement Commission and Takeovers Panel. There has been a total of 13 redundancy processes…

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Arena Williams

Member for Manurewa · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    What aides-mémoire, briefings, memos, notes, reports, or any other advice, if any, has the Minister or their Office received during the week beginning 24 August 2026, listed by agency, title and date received?

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

I regularly request and receive advice on a range of topics. In the interest of transparency, a list of briefings and reports received by my office from the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment (MBIE) is regularly published on…

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Arena Williams

Member for Manurewa · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    What papers, if any, did the Minister take to Cabinet during the week beginning 24 August 2026, by title and date?

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

I regularly take papers to Cabinet across a range of topics. In the interest of transparency, I proactively release papers considered by Cabinet on the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment website…

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Megan Woods

Member for Wigram · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    What assessment has the Minister made of the potential effects of increased aluminium-extrusion imports on skills retention, workforce capability, investment, and productive capacity in New Zealand manufacturing, if any?

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

Under the Trade (Safeguard Measures) Act 2014, MBIE carries out the investigation and provides me with advice. I cannot comment on the investigation underway.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Megan Woods

Member for Wigram · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    What further information, if any, has the Minister requested in relation to a possible provisional safeguard duty for aluminium extrusions, and on what dates was it requested?

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

Under the Trade (Safeguard Measures) Act 2014, MBIE carries out the investigation and provides me with information and advice to support my decision. The Aluminium Extruders Association of New Zealand (ALENZ) requested consideration of a…

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Megan Woods

Member for Wigram · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    How many MBIE officials or managers have held responsibility for the aluminium-extrusions safeguard investigation since the application was received, if any?

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

Since the aluminium extrusions safeguard investigation application was received, responsibility for trade remedies has been held by three General Managers, and two managers reporting to them. Day-to-day management of the Trade Remedies…

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Megan Woods

Member for Wigram · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    What advice, if any, has the Minister received on the application of section 14 of the Trade (Safeguard Measures) Act 2014 to the aluminium-extrusions safeguard investigation?

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

I received advice on a possible provisional safeguard duty from MBIE on 4 August and 1 September 2026. Following advice from MBIE, I have decided not to impose provisional safeguard duties at this stage. This position relates only to…

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Megan Woods

Member for Wigram · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    Has the Minister received a recommendation from the chief executive of MBIE on a provisional safeguard duty in respect of aluminium extrusions; if so, on what date was it received?

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

Yes, on 4 August 2026 and 1 September 2026.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Megan Woods

Member for Wigram · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    When does the Minister expect to decide whether to impose a provisional safeguard duty in respect of aluminium extrusions?

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

Following advice from MBIE, I have decided not to impose provisional safeguard duties at this stage. This position relates only to ALENZ’s request for provisional duties and does not prejudge the outcome of the wider safeguard…

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Megan Woods

Member for Wigram · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    Has the Minister or any representative of the Minister met with workers, unions, employers, or industry representatives affected by the aluminium-extrusions safeguard investigation; if so, on what dates and with whom?

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

The investigation is being carried out by MBIE officials, and they meet regularly with interested parties as part of the investigation.

Questions published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Megan Woods

Member for Wigram · Labour Party

Questions

  • 37858 (matches this search)

    What information has the Minister or his office received on the change in the volume of aluminium-extrusion imports during the most recent six-month period compared with the corresponding six-month period a year earlier, if any?

  • 37859 (matches this search)

    What information has the Minister received on the volume of aluminium-extrusion imports entering New Zealand between the receipt of the safeguard application and the initiation of the investigation, if any?

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

I cannot comment on the investigation underway. However, I expect that more information will be made available in due course.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Megan Woods

Member for Wigram · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    How many calendar days elapsed between the receipt of the aluminium-extrusions safeguard application and the initiation of the associated safeguard investigation, if any?

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

MBIE received the application for a safeguard investigation into aluminium extrusions on 21 January 2026. Following MBIE’s assessment of the application, I was provided with advice on 14 May recommending a safeguard investigation be…

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Arena Williams

Member for Manurewa · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    What aides-mémoire, briefings, memos, notes, reports, or any other advice, if any, has the Minister or their Office received during the week beginning 17 August 2026, listed by agency, title and date received?

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

I regularly request and receive advice on a range of topics. In the interest of transparency, a list of briefings and reports received by my office from the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment (MBIE) is regularly published on…

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Arena Williams

Member for Manurewa · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    What papers, if any, did the Minister take to Cabinet during the week beginning 17 August 2026, by title and date?

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

I regularly take papers to Cabinet across a range of topics. In the interest of transparency, I proactively release papers considered by Cabinet on the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment website…

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Arena Williams

Member for Manurewa · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    When will the "exposure draft of the regulations" for toy standards in New Zealand be released for public consultation; and how, if at all, can kiwi parents have their say?

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

I intend to release an exposure draft of the regulations for public consultation before the regulations are finalised. Details of the consultation process, including how members of the public can make submissions, will be published at the…

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Arena Williams

Member for Manurewa · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    When MBIE states that "the European and American standards provide a comparable level of safety to the Australia/New Zealand joint standard" for children's toys sold in New Zealand, how is "comparable level" being assessed?

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

"Comparable level of safety" refers to an assessment of the requirements relating to choking and airway hazards addressed by the regulations. The technical requirements and testing methods across the European, American, and…

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Arena Williams

Member for Manurewa · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    When MBIE states that "the European and American standards provide a comparable level of safety to the Australia/New Zealand joint standard" for children's toys sold in New Zealand; what exactly is meant by "a comparable level"?

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

It means the standards achieve substantially the same safety outcome in relation to the choking and airway hazards addressed by the standards. This is because the technical requirements and testing methods are largely the same.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Arena Williams

Member for Manurewa · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    What are the "three internationally recognised safety standards" that will apply "when a parent buys a toy for their child" in New Zealand, and where can New Zealand parents see the definition of each standard?

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

Subject to consultation and the final regulations, suppliers would be able to comply with: • AS/NZS ISO 8124.1:2023; • EN 71-1:2014+A1:2018; or • ASTM F963-17. The regulations would also recognise ISO 8124-1:2022, which is the same as…

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Arena Williams

Member for Manurewa · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    What exactly is the definition of the "toy standards of the United States", and what methodology, if any, is being used to compare that to the current New Zealand standard?

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

The relevant United States standard is ASTM F963-17. In developing the proposed changes, consideration was given to Australia's assessment that the relevant provisions of the American standard provide a comparable level of safety to AS/NZS…

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Arena Williams

Member for Manurewa · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    Does he agree with Consumer New Zealand that "we need our government to introduce a product safety system in Aotearoa that reflects the risks we currently face in our marketplaces"; if so, what is he doing to address consumer safety in…

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

New Zealand's product safety framework must continue to adapt to changing consumer markets. The Government is progressing a range of product safety initiatives and reforms. Products supplied through online marketplaces are required to…

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Arena Williams

Member for Manurewa · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    Does he agree with Consumer New Zealand that for many products sold online, there has been no independent testing before they reach New Zealand homes; if so, does the Government's changes to toy standards include online sales?

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

The proposed toy safety regulations apply to toys supplied in New Zealand regardless of the sales channel through which they are sold. This includes toys sold online where New Zealand consumer and product safety laws apply.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Arena Williams

Member for Manurewa · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    What, if anything, is he doing to address the availability of potentially dangerous toys in 2026 through online marketplaces such as AliExpress?

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

The Government is modernising toy safety regulations to ensure that toys supplied in New Zealand meet recognised international safety requirements. Suppliers must comply with New Zealand consumer and product safety laws regardless of…

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Arena Williams

Member for Manurewa · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    Does he agree with the Hamilton mum, quoted in the Waikato Times on 20 July 2026, that, regarding changes to toy safety standards, the Gov­ern­ment appeared to be pri­or­it­ising rel­at­ively mod­est sav­ings for busi­nesses over par­ents’…

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

Proposed changes are intended to maintain toy safety while reducing unnecessary regulatory differences between New Zealand and Australia. The proposed standards provide a comparable level of safety to the current requirements.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Arena Williams

Member for Manurewa · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    Does he share the concern of the Hamilton mum who campaigned against asbestos in toys, quoted in the Waikato Times on 20 July 2026, that proposed Government changes to toy safety regulations will put Kiwi kids at further risk from…

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

The proposed changes are intended to maintain toy safety while reducing unnecessary regulatory differences between New Zealand and Australia. The proposed standards provide a comparable level of safety to the current requirements.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Arena Williams

Member for Manurewa · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    What discussions, if any, has he had with retailers of recalled children’s sand products since the AUT findings on 2 July that asbestos fibres could become airborne during simulated play?

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

The investigation is being carried out by MBIE officials, and they meet regularly with interested parties as part of the investigation.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Arena Williams

Member for Manurewa · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    Does the Government plan to do any investigation into whether Kmart’s handling of the recall of asbestos contaminated sand products, including the information provided to consumers about the health risk, complied with the Consumer…

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

Compliance and enforcement matters are primarily the responsibility of the relevant regulatory agencies, such as the Commerce Commission.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Arena Williams

Member for Manurewa · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    Does he stand by his statement of 2 July that he is taking the matter of AUT findings of airborne asbestos in children's sand products "seriously"; if so, what actions, if any, has he taken in the last 7 weeks?

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

Yes. I have sought and received advice from officials on potential actions that may be taken in response to asbestos-contaminated sand products. I have been actively considering that advice and expect to make an announcement on my response…

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Arena Williams

Member for Manurewa · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    What advice, if any, has he received from officials since the AUT findings were released on 2 July about airborne asbestos in children's sand products, and what action, if any, has he taken in response to that advice?

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

I have sought and received advice from officials on potential actions that may be taken in response to asbestos-contaminated sand products. I have been actively considering that advice and expect to make an announcement on my response…

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Arena Williams

Member for Manurewa · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    Is the Minister concerned that Kmart is reported to have sold 67,000 contaminated asbestos sand products in New Zealand?

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

I am concerned that asbestos-contaminated sand products have been sold to New Zealand consumers. I have sought and received advice from officials on potential responses and have been actively considering that advice and expect to make an…

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Arena Williams

Member for Manurewa · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    Given the success of the Christchurch parents in the Disputes Tribunal which ordered Kmart to pay them $15,185.42 for the costs of asbestos testing and remediation, is he concerned that low-income parents might have a similar claim but…

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

New Zealand consumers have a range of avenues available to seek redress. In the first instance, I encourage consumers to contact the supplier directly to try to resolve the issue.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Arena Williams

Member for Manurewa · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    Will the Minister commit to reviewing the Government’s response to the Kmart asbestos-sand recall in light of the Disputes Tribunal decision, including whether changes are needed to ensure consumers receive accurate risk information and…

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

The Government is considering whether improvements to product safety settings are required in response to issues relating to asbestos-contaminated sand products. I am currently receiving advice on these matters and will make announcements…

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Arena Williams

Member for Manurewa · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    Given the Disputes Tribunal finding in favour of the Christchurch parents vs Kmart, will the Minister encourage Kmart to review and compensate other affected families?

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

I expect all suppliers to comply with their obligations under New Zealand consumer law, including the Consumer Guarantees Act.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Arena Williams

Member for Manurewa · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    Does the Minister have confidence that the current product-recall system is capable of responding appropriately when a children’s product is found to contain a hazardous substance such as asbestos; if so, what evidence supports that…

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

New Zealand’s product safety and recall framework is designed to ensure unsafe products can be removed from the market and consumers are informed of identified risks, as demonstrated by the recall of asbestos-containing sand products.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Arena Williams

Member for Manurewa · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    Does the Minister believe that consumers should not have to take a major retailer to the Disputes Tribunal to recover reasonable costs arising from an unsafe product recall; if so, what will he do to prevent other families facing the same…

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

The Government expects suppliers to meet their legal obligations.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Arena Williams

Member for Manurewa · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    Following the Disputes Tribunal decision, has the Minister asked for any advice on how many families who purchased the recalled Kmart sand have incurred costs beyond the price of the product itself; if so, how many, and what compensation…

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

I have not received advice on the number of consumers who may have incurred costs beyond the purchase price of recalled products, nor on any compensation arrangements reached between individual consumers and suppliers.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Arena Williams

Member for Manurewa · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    Does the Minister accept the Disputes Tribunal’s finding about Kmart and asbestos contaminated children's sand products; if so, what action is he taking in response to those findings?

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

I acknowledge the decision of the Disputes Tribunal. It would not be appropriate for me to comment on the merits of an individual case.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Arena Williams

Member for Manurewa · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    Following the Disputes Tribunal decision, will the Minister ask MBIE to review whether the existing consumer protection framework is adequate when consumers incur substantial costs responding to a recalled product that is subsequently…

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

Officials continually monitor the effectiveness of consumer protection settings and provide advice on potential improvements where appropriate.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Arena Williams

Member for Manurewa · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    Does the Minister consider it acceptable that Christchurch parents had to spend more than $15,000 testing, cleaning and remediating their home before receiving compensation from Kmart; if so, why?

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

I do not intend to comment on the circumstances of a specific Disputes Tribunal case.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Arena Williams

Member for Manurewa · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    Has the Minister sought advice on whether Kmart’s original advice to consumers that the contaminated sand presented a low risk was accurate; if not, why not?

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs

Answer

The content of a product recall notice is a matter for the supplier issuing the recall. Kmart's statements to consumers are therefore best addressed by Kmart itself.