Skip to main content

Written questions

Search written questions to Ministers and the replies they have received.

Filters
Asked by All MPs
Minister All Ministers
Portfolio Immigration
Question published between

Dates refer to when the question was published, and are inclusive.

Showing 201 to 250 of 598 written question sets.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Ricardo Menéndez March

List MP · Green Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    Further to Written Question 6242 (2026), since 01 January 2015, how many persons considered to be "fleeing", if any, where Immigration Compliance Officers relied on section 328 of the Immigration Act 2009, were later confirmed to be…

Answered by

Hon Erica Stanford

Member for East Coast Bays · National Party · Minister of Immigration

Answer

I am advised that immigration records show no such instances.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Ricardo Menéndez March

List MP · Green Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    Further to Written Question 6242 (2026), what examples, scenarios, or case studies, if any, were given to Immigration Compliance Officers regarding what constitutes “fleeing” under section 328 of the Immigration Act 2009?

Answered by

Hon Erica Stanford

Member for East Coast Bays · National Party · Minister of Immigration

Answer

I am advised that Compliance officer core training addresses how to implement the provisions of section 328. There are training modules that Compliance officers must complete and these cover the range of core competencies for all…

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Ricardo Menéndez March

List MP · Green Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    Further to Written Question 6242 (2026), is “fleeing” assessed solely on observed behaviour, or are officers required to establish intent before relying on section 328 of the Immigration Act 2009?

Answered by

Hon Erica Stanford

Member for East Coast Bays · National Party · Minister of Immigration

Answer

If the Member is able to provide me with an example where the observed behaviour of "fleeing" does not establish an intent to flee then I will be better placed to answer his question.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Ricardo Menéndez March

List MP · Green Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    Further to Written Question 6242 (2026), what specific conduct, if any, may lead an Immigration Compliance Officer to conclude that a person is “fleeing” during a compliance encounter?

Answered by

Hon Erica Stanford

Member for East Coast Bays · National Party · Minister of Immigration

Answer

The most common synonym for flee is "run". Other synonyms include: depart, escape quickly, move evasively, take off, and leave with haste.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Ricardo Menéndez March

List MP · Green Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    Further to Written Question 6242 (2026), can a person be considered to be “fleeing” where they do not know that the individual approaching them is an Immigration Compliance Officer?

Answered by

Hon Erica Stanford

Member for East Coast Bays · National Party · Minister of Immigration

Answer

Immigration Compliance Officers wear uniforms and clearly identify themselves by showing their immigration warrant card.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Ricardo Menéndez March

List MP · Green Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    Further to Written Question 6242 (2026), does Immigration New Zealand distinguish between “fleeing” and a person merely walking away, declining engagement, leaving a workplace, or exercising a right not to answer questions, and if so, how?

Answered by

Hon Erica Stanford

Member for East Coast Bays · National Party · Minister of Immigration

Answer

I refer the member to my answer to WPQ 20109 and my earlier answer to WPQ 6242.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Ricardo Menéndez March

List MP · Green Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    Further to Written Question 6242 (2026), how many Immigration Compliance Officers, if any, currently hold powers relating to detention under the Immigration Act 2009, broken down by region?

Answered by

Hon Erica Stanford

Member for East Coast Bays · National Party · Minister of Immigration

Answer

I am advised there are currently 54 in total nationally. This includes 25 in Auckland, 4 in Hamilton-Tauranga, 7 in Porirua-Napier, and 18 in Christchurch-Nelson teams.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Ricardo Menéndez March

List MP · Green Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    Further to Written Question 6242 (2026), what reviews, if any, has Immigration New Zealand undertaken, of whether ethnicity, nationality, language ability, or migrant-associated workplaces may influence compliance officers’ assessments of…

Answered by

Hon Erica Stanford

Member for East Coast Bays · National Party · Minister of Immigration

Answer

I am advised that Immigration New Zealand is always alert to any concerns regarding bias in their assessments and exercise of compliance powers. There is agency-wide training on how to identify and avoid unconscious bias, and concerning…

Questions published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Ricardo Menéndez March

List MP · Green Party

Questions

  • 20116 (matches this search)

    Further to Written Question 6242 (2026), what criteria, if any, distinguish “reasonable suspicion” from ordinary nervousness, reluctance to engage, language difficulties, or cultural differences during immigration compliance encounters?

  • 20169 (matches this search)

    What guidance, if any, is provided to Immigration New Zealand officers to ensure that requests for identification or nationality information are exercised consistently with the New Zealand Human Rights Act 1993?

  • 20170 (matches this search)

    What guidance, if any, is provided to Immigration New Zealand officers to ensure that requests for identification or nationality information are exercised consistently with the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990?

Answered by

Hon Erica Stanford

Member for East Coast Bays · National Party · Minister of Immigration

Answer

I am advised that all Compliance officers receive extensive training including on the powers they have under the Immigration Act 2009 what types of observations and behaviours may contribute to forming 'good cause to suspect' in the range…

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Ricardo Menéndez March

List MP · Green Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    Further to Written Question 6242 (2026), since 01 January 2021, how many complaints, if any, relating to immigration compliance officers stopping, questioning, or approaching individuals based on perceived suspicious behaviour have been…

Answered by

Hon Erica Stanford

Member for East Coast Bays · National Party · Minister of Immigration

Answer

I am advised that this information is not available in an easily reportable format. It is not in the public interest to divert staff from their core duties to manually collate this information.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Ricardo Menéndez March

List MP · Green Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    Since 01 January 2021, how many immigration compliance operations, if any, conducted roadside stops, checkpoints, or the stopping of vehicles for immigration-related purposes, broken down by operation name and activity type?

Answered by

Hon Erica Stanford

Member for East Coast Bays · National Party · Minister of Immigration

Answer

Immigration officers do not have a general stopping power.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Ricardo Menéndez March

List MP · Green Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    Since 01 January 2021, what immigration compliance operations, if any, similar to Operation Indigo have been undertaken in the past five years, broken down by date of operation, sectors targeted, number of Full Time Equivalent staff…

Answered by

Hon Erica Stanford

Member for East Coast Bays · National Party · Minister of Immigration

Answer

I am advised that this information is not available in an easily reportable format. It is not in the public interest to divert staff from their core duties to manually collate this information.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Ricardo Menéndez March

List MP · Green Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    How many employers, if any, were investigated or subject to enforcement action as part of Operation Indigo, broken down by violation and enforcement action taken?

Answered by

Hon Erica Stanford

Member for East Coast Bays · National Party · Minister of Immigration

Answer

I am advised that Immigration Compliance is considering issuing an infringement notice for one employer.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Ricardo Menéndez March

List MP · Green Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    How many people, if any, were found to be unlawfully in New Zealand as a result of Operation Indigo broken down by nationality, gender, age, visa type and violation?

Answered by

Hon Erica Stanford

Member for East Coast Bays · National Party · Minister of Immigration

Answer

I am advised one person was identified as unlawful. It is not in the public interest to provide further information in order to protect the person's privacy.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Ricardo Menéndez March

List MP · Green Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    How many people, if any, were approached, questioned, or asked to provide identification as part of Operation Indigo, broken down by nationality, visa type, ethnicity, gender, and age?

Answered by

Hon Erica Stanford

Member for East Coast Bays · National Party · Minister of Immigration

Answer

I am advised that this information is not available in an easily reportable format. It is not in the public interest to divert staff from their core duties to manually collate this information.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Ricardo Menéndez March

List MP · Green Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    What was the total cost of Operation Indigo, broken down by staffing, travel, accommodation, operational, and contractor costs?

Answered by

Hon Erica Stanford

Member for East Coast Bays · National Party · Minister of Immigration

Answer

I am advised that this information is not available in an easily reportable format. It is not in the public interest to divert staff from their core duties to manually collate this information.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Ricardo Menéndez March

List MP · Green Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    In relation to Operation Indigo, how many Immigration New Zealand staff or officers, if any, were involved in the operation, broken down by position name and agency involved?

Answered by

Hon Erica Stanford

Member for East Coast Bays · National Party · Minister of Immigration

Answer

I am advised that 4 Compliance officers were in attendance and 1 Compliance manager who attended for some of the operation.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Ricardo Menéndez March

List MP · Green Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    What assessment, if any, has the Ministry made of the comparative rates of overstaying or immigration non-compliance between visitor visa holders and entrants from visa waiver countries?

Answered by

Hon Erica Stanford

Member for East Coast Bays · National Party · Minister of Immigration

Answer

Information on overstayers has been publicly available on the Immigration New Zealand website for the last nine months. The top five overstayer nationalities by % are Tonga, Samoa, Malaysia, Fiji, and India. Of these Tonga, Samoa, Fiji and…

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Ricardo Menéndez March

List MP · Green Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    Since 01 January 2021, how many people from visa waiver countries, if any, were identified as having breached their visa conditions after entry into New Zealand broken down per year by nationality?

Answered by

Hon Erica Stanford

Member for East Coast Bays · National Party · Minister of Immigration

Answer

I am advised that this information is not available in an easily reportable format. It is not in the public interest to divert staff from their core duties to manually collate this information.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Ricardo Menéndez March

List MP · Green Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    Since 01 January 2021, how many, if any, of the visitor visa applications declined on bona fide grounds, were from visa waiver countries, broken down by nationality and year?

Answered by

Hon Erica Stanford

Member for East Coast Bays · National Party · Minister of Immigration

Answer

I refer the Member to the attached document.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Ricardo Menéndez March

List MP · Green Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    Since 01 January 2021, how many applications, if any, for a visitor visa were declined on the grounds that the applicant was not considered to be bona fide, broken down per year by nationality, gender, and age?

Answered by

Hon Erica Stanford

Member for East Coast Bays · National Party · Minister of Immigration

Answer

I refer the Member to the attached document.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Ricardo Menéndez March

List MP · Green Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    Will data be collected on the ethnicity or citizenship status of persons subject to immigration compliance identity requests under the proposed amendments to section 280 of the Immigration Act 2009, and if so, for what purpose?

Answered by

Hon Erica Stanford

Member for East Coast Bays · National Party · Minister of Immigration

Answer

I am advised that Immigration is exploring options to collect and report on information relevant to the proposed amendments to section 280 of the Immigration Act 2009.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Ricardo Menéndez March

List MP · Green Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    Will Immigration New Zealand officers be required to record the grounds relied upon when requesting identification or nationality information under the proposed amendments section 280 of the Immigration Act 2009, and if so, how?

Answered by

Hon Erica Stanford

Member for East Coast Bays · National Party · Minister of Immigration

Answer

I am advised that all operational activity must be supported by contemporaneous notes and recorded in INZ systems to ensure transparency and accountability. An immigration officer exercises powers under section 280 will be required to…

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Ricardo Menéndez March

List MP · Green Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    Since 01 January 2015, how many deportation liability notices, if any, were issued to temporary visa holders for breaches of visa conditions, broken down by visa category, breach type, ethnicity, gender, and age?

Answered by

Hon Erica Stanford

Member for East Coast Bays · National Party · Minister of Immigration

Answer

I am advised that since 1 January 2015 Compliance has issued Deportation Liability Notices under IA09 s157(5)(a) to 322 individuals. I refer the Member to the attached document for this information.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Ricardo Menéndez March

List MP · Green Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    What evidence, if any, demonstrated that existing employer compliance, accreditation, and deportation liability processes were insufficient prior to the introduction of the Immigration (Enhanced Risk Management) Amendment Bill?

Answered by

Hon Erica Stanford

Member for East Coast Bays · National Party · Minister of Immigration

Answer

I refer the member to the information provided in the materials released [link:…

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Ricardo Menéndez March

List MP · Green Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    Since 01 January 2015, how many New Zealand citizens or residents, if any, have been asked by Immigration New Zealand officers to provide proof of identity, nationality, or country of birth during immigration compliance activities broken…

Answered by

Hon Erica Stanford

Member for East Coast Bays · National Party · Minister of Immigration

Answer

I am advised that Compliance does not collect information on New Zealand citizens or Permanent Resident Visa holders.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Ricardo Menéndez March

List MP · Green Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    What assessment, if any, has been undertaken regarding the likelihood that New Zealand citizens or residents may be asked to identify themselves during immigration compliance operations under the proposed amendments to section 280 of the…

Answered by

Hon Erica Stanford

Member for East Coast Bays · National Party · Minister of Immigration

Answer

I am advised that no specific assessment have been undertaken on the likelihood of New Zealand citizens and residents being asked for identity-based information under the proposed amendments to section 280 of the Immigration Act 2009, as…

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Ricardo Menéndez March

List MP · Green Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    What assessment, if any, has been undertaken regarding the proportionality of applying detention or compulsory identification powers to temporary visa holders who may have committed minor or technical breaches of visa conditions?

Answered by

Hon Erica Stanford

Member for East Coast Bays · National Party · Minister of Immigration

Answer

I refer the member to the information provided in the materials released to support the introduction of the Immigration (Enhanced Risk Management) Bill, including the collated Regulatory Impact Statements.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Ricardo Menéndez March

List MP · Green Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    Since 01 January 2020, how many incidents, if any, involved Immigration New Zealand officers requesting individuals to provide their nationality, country of birth, or identity documents under section 280 of the Immigration Act 2009, broken…

Answered by

Hon Erica Stanford

Member for East Coast Bays · National Party · Minister of Immigration

Answer

I am advised that this information is not available in an easily reportable format. It is not in the public interest to divert staff from their core duties to manually collate this information.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Phil Twyford

Member for Te Atatū · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    How many Visas, if any, have been cancelled, during the week of 4 May 2026, broken down by age, gender, ethnicity, visa type and reason?

Answered by

Hon Erica Stanford

Member for East Coast Bays · National Party · Minister of Immigration

Answer

I refer the Member to the attached document. I am advised the reasons for all cancellations are not held in a reportable format. To obtain the information, a manual review of each visa record would be required, and the public interest…

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Phil Twyford

Member for Te Atatū · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    How many visa applications, if any, were approved, during week of 4 May 2026, broken down by visa type?

Answered by

Hon Erica Stanford

Member for East Coast Bays · National Party · Minister of Immigration

Answer

I refer the Member to the attached document.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Phil Twyford

Member for Te Atatū · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    How many visa applications, if any, were rejected, during week of 4 May 2026; broken down by visa type?

Answered by

Hon Erica Stanford

Member for East Coast Bays · National Party · Minister of Immigration

Answer

I refer the Member to the attached document. I am advised the reasons for all decline decisions are not held in a reportable format. To obtain the information, a manual review of each visa record would be required, and the public interest…

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Phil Twyford

Member for Te Atatū · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    What was the average time it took to process visa applications, if any, during the week of 4 May 2026; broken down by visa type?

Answered by

Hon Erica Stanford

Member for East Coast Bays · National Party · Minister of Immigration

Answer

I refer the Member to the attached document.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Phil Twyford

Member for Te Atatū · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    How many FTEs, if any, are currently working on monitoring or addressing migrant exploitation at Immigration NZ, MBIE or any other relevant party?

Answered by

Hon Erica Stanford

Member for East Coast Bays · National Party · Minister of Immigration

Answer

I am advised that at least 256 staff members have a role in monitoring and addressing migrant exploitation. This may make up all or part of their workload. It is not possible to break down the FTE further.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Phil Twyford

Member for Te Atatū · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    What was the nature of the work, if any was done, by Immigration NZ, MBIE or any other relevant party on the subject of monitoring or addressing migrant exploitation during the week of 4 May 2026?

Answered by

Hon Erica Stanford

Member for East Coast Bays · National Party · Minister of Immigration

Answer

I am advised that each week MBIE staff work on a range of matters addressing and monitoring migrant exploitation including reporting, policy development, assessing applications for migrant exploitation protection visas, taking compliance…

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Phil Twyford

Member for Te Atatū · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    What advice or updates, if any, did the Minister receive about the Accredited Employment Work Visa during the week of 4 May 2026?

Answered by

Hon Erica Stanford

Member for East Coast Bays · National Party · Minister of Immigration

Answer

For the week commencing 4 May 2026, I received advice on English language requirements for AEWV skill level 3 occupations. In addition, I received updates on key timelines measures for the final week in April, monthly insights for AEWV…

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Phil Twyford

Member for Te Atatū · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    What advice or updates, if any, did the Minister receive on the subject of the Parent Visa Boost during the week of 4 May 2026?

Answered by

Hon Erica Stanford

Member for East Coast Bays · National Party · Minister of Immigration

Answer

A general update.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Phil Twyford

Member for Te Atatū · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    What was the total amount, if any, of visa fees paid to Immigration NZ during the week of 4 May 2026?

Answered by

Hon Erica Stanford

Member for East Coast Bays · National Party · Minister of Immigration

Answer

I am advised that the total visa application fees received by Immigration New Zealand during the week of 4 May 2026 to 10 May 2026 was NZ$5,535,891 (excluding GST).

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Francisco Hernandez

List MP · Green Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    How, if at all, has artificial intelligence been deployed in a customer service function in the Minister’s departments, agencies, crown entities and any other bodies that the Minister is responsible for, if any?

Answered by

Hon Erica Stanford

Member for East Coast Bays · National Party · Minister of Immigration

Answer

As Minister for Immigration, I have no responsibility for any government departments, Ministries, agencies, crown entities or other bodies. Immigration New Zealand is a branch of the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment (MBIE).…

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Phil Twyford

Member for Te Atatū · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    What aides-mémoire, briefings, memos, notes, reports, or any other advice, if any, has the Minister or their Office received during the week beginning 4 May 2026, listed by agency, title and date received?

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Associate Minister of Immigration

Answer

The documents I received from MBIE in the week beginning 4 May 2026 are listed in the table attached. This list includes formal briefings and aides-mémoire where I am recorded as the main recipient as the Associate Minister of Immigration.…

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Phil Twyford

Member for Te Atatū · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    What aides-mémoire, briefings, memos, notes, reports, or any other advice, if any, has the Minister or their Office received during the week beginning 4 May 2026, listed by agency, title and date received?

Answered by

Hon Casey Costello

List MP · NZ First Party · Associate Minister of Immigration

Answer

I refer the Member to the attached table.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Phil Twyford

Member for Te Atatū · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    What aides-mémoire, briefings, memos, notes, reports, or any other advice, if any, has the Minister or their Office received during the week beginning 4 May 2026, listed by agency, title and date received?

Answered by

Hon Erica Stanford

Member for East Coast Bays · National Party · Minister of Immigration

Answer

The documents I received from MBIE in the week beginning 4 May 2026 are listed in the table attached. This list includes formal briefings and aides-mémoire where the Minister of Immigration is recorded as the main recipient. Papers…

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Phil Twyford

Member for Te Atatū · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    What papers, if any, did the Minister take to Cabinet during the week beginning 4 May 2026, by title and date?

Answered by

Cameron Brewer

Member for Upper Harbour · National Party · Associate Minister of Immigration

Answer

None

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Phil Twyford

Member for Te Atatū · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    What papers, if any, did the Minister take to Cabinet during the week beginning 4 May 2026, by title and date?

Answered by

Hon Casey Costello

List MP · NZ First Party · Associate Minister of Immigration

Answer

As Associate Minister of Immigration, none.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Phil Twyford

Member for Te Atatū · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    What papers, if any, did the Minister take to Cabinet during the week beginning 4 May 2026, by title and date?

Answered by

Hon Erica Stanford

Member for East Coast Bays · National Party · Minister of Immigration

Answer

None.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Phil Twyford

Member for Te Atatū · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    How many Visas, if any, have been cancelled, during the week of 27th April 2026, broken down by age, gender, ethnicity, visa type and reason?

Answered by

Hon Erica Stanford

Member for East Coast Bays · National Party · Minister of Immigration

Answer

I refer the Member to the attached document. I am advised the reasons for all cancellations are not held in a reportable format. To obtain the information, a manual review of each visa record would be required, and the public interest…

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Phil Twyford

Member for Te Atatū · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    How many visa applications, if any, were approved, during week of 27th April 2026, broken down by visa type?

Answered by

Hon Erica Stanford

Member for East Coast Bays · National Party · Minister of Immigration

Answer

I refer the Member to the attached document.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Phil Twyford

Member for Te Atatū · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    What was the average time it took to process visa applications, if any, during the week of 27th April 2026; broken down by visa type?

Answered by

Hon Erica Stanford

Member for East Coast Bays · National Party · Minister of Immigration

Answer

I refer the Member to the attached document.

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Phil Twyford

Member for Te Atatū · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    How many visa applications, if any, were rejected, during week of 27th April 2026; broken down by visa type?

Answered by

Hon Erica Stanford

Member for East Coast Bays · National Party · Minister of Immigration

Answer

I refer the Member to the attached document. I am advised the reasons for all decline decisions are not held in a reportable format. To obtain the information, a manual review of each visa record would be required, and the public interest…

Question published
Reply lodged

Asked by

Phil Twyford

Member for Te Atatū · Labour Party

Question

  • (matches this search)

    How many FTEs, if any, are currently working on monitoring or addressing migrant exploitation at Immigration NZ, MBIE or any other relevant party?

Answered by

Hon Erica Stanford

Member for East Coast Bays · National Party · Minister of Immigration

Answer

I am advised that at least 256 staff members have a role in monitoring and addressing migrant exploitation. This may make up all or part of their workload. It is not possible to break down the FTE further.